php - OutOfRangeException vs. OutOfBoundsException

Question

PHP defines two SPL exceptions for invalid keys:

OutOfRangeException: Exception thrown when an illegal index was requested. This represents errors that should be detected at compile time.

OutOfBoundsException: Exception thrown if a value is not a valid key. This represents errors that cannot be detected at compile time.

As PHP isn't a compiled language the distinction between compile-time and run-time seems strange and thus I am finding it hard to understand which exception to use when.

Currently my understanding is that one should throw...
... OutOfRangeException if the key is fundamentally and inherently malformed, e.g. if an array is passed as a key.
... OutOfBoundsException if the key is generally okay, but isn't in some boundaries, e.g. if 100 is passed but 50 is the maximum key.

Is that understanding correct?

Answer 1

While PHP doesn't have a classic "compile time" (or a compiler that do a lot of static checks for that matter) I'd treat "compile time" as "rather static stuff I did wrong when writing the code" and "run time" as "my logic, input or validation was off at some point".

So my suggestion would be to treat it like this:

"Compile Time" / "OutOfRangeException": The error can always be fixed in the source code without or with very little logic.

I always take numbers from 1-10 and you put in 11

---

"Run Time" / "OutOfBoundsException": The error is due to wrong use at runtime.

You created me and told me to take values from 1 to 5 then you put in 7. Doesn't compute

or

You request an index that is not there because you didn't put it there like you should

---

Sample:

I'd expect an SplFixedArray to throw an OutOfBoundsException because it's size is dynamic and can chance at runtime while I'd expect something like a Calender::getMonthName to throw and OutOfRangeException because the number of month are definitely fixed at "compile/write" time.

Array object sample:

Say $array is an object that implements ArrayAccess you could throw an OutOfBoundsException in these circumstances:

$array['bar'];
$array[7];

As the values are what you could expect for ArrayAccess but it doesn't make sense in the case of an SplFixedArray(5). Alternatives would be DomainException or maybe RangeException

An OutOfRangeException in these cases:

$calendar->getMonth(15);

As putting an array or a new class there is definitely some bigger logic flaw in the code that usually results from a simple "oh, i put in the wrong variable" error by a programmer. An (maybe preferable) alternative would be UnexpectedValueException and good old InvalidArgumentException.

For cases like:

$array[array()];
$array[new StdClass];

some of the alternative exceptions seem more fitting.

Comparisons with the Java world on which exception to use when are not always applicable as Java Developers have an additions issue to deal with.

Checked/Unchecked exceptions. With many people arguing that everything that isn't a runtime exception has very limited use in Java / should not be used much internally) those names have lost some of their original meaning and intent.