tensorflow - How to deal with multi step time series forecasting in multivariate LSTM in keras

Question

I am trying to do multi-step time series forecasting using multivariate LSTM in Keras. Specifically, I have two variables (var1 and var2) for each time step originally. Having followed the online tutorial here, I decided to use data at time (t-2) and (t-1) to predict the value of var2 at time step t. As sample data table shows, I am using the first 4 columns as input, Y as output. The code I have developed can be seen here, but I have got three questions.

   var1(t-2)  var2(t-2)  var1(t-1)  var2(t-1)  var2(t)
2        1.5       -0.8        0.9       -0.5     -0.2
3        0.9       -0.5       -0.1       -0.2      0.2
4       -0.1       -0.2       -0.3        0.2      0.4
5       -0.3        0.2       -0.7        0.4      0.6
6       -0.7        0.4        0.2        0.6      0.7

1. Q1: I have trained an LSTM model with the data above. This model does well in predicting the value of var2 at time step t. However, what if I want to predict var2 at time step t+1. I feel it is hard because the model cannot tell me the value of var1 at time step t. If I want to do it, how should I modify the code to build the model?
2. Q2: I have seen this question asked a lot, but I am still confused. In my example, what should be the correct time step in [samples, time steps, features] 1 or 2?
3. Q3: I just started studying LSTMs. I have read here that one of the biggest advantages of LSTM is that it learns the temporal dependence/sliding window size by itself, then why must we always covert time series data into format like the table above?

Update: LSTM result (blue line is the training seq, orange line is the ground truth, green is the prediction)

Answer 1

Question 1:

From your table, I see you have a sliding window over a single sequence, making many smaller sequences with 2 steps.

• For predicting t, you take first line of your table as input
• For predicting t+1, you take the second line as input.

If you're not using the table: see question 3

Question 2:

Assuming you're using that table as input, where it's clearly a sliding window case taking two time steps as input, your timeSteps is 2.

You should probably work as if var1 and var2 were features in the same sequence:

• input_shape = (2,2) - Two time steps and two features/vars.

Question 3:

We do not need to make tables like that or build a sliding window case. That is one possible approach.

Your model is actually capable of learning things and deciding the size of this window itself.

If on one hand your model is capable of learning long time dependencies, allowing you not to use windows, on the other hand, it may learn to identify different behaviors at the beginning and at the middle of a sequence. In this case, if you want to predict using sequences that start from the middle (not including the beginning), your model may work as if it were the beginning and predict a different behavior. Using windows eliminate this very long influence. Which is better may depend on testing, I guess.

Not using windows:

If your data has 800 steps, feed all the 800 steps at once for training.

Here, we will need to separate two models, one for training, another for predicting. In training, we will take advantage of the parameter return_sequences=True. This means that for each input step, we will get an output step.

For predicting later, we will want only one output, then we will use return_sequences= False. And in case we are going to use the predicted outputs as inputs for following steps, we are going to use a stateful=True layer.

Training:

Have your input data shaped as (1, 799, 2), 1 sequence, taking the steps from 1 to 799. Both vars in the same sequence (2 features).

Have your target data (Y) shaped also as (1, 799, 2), taking the same steps shifted, from 2 to 800.

Build a model with return_sequences=True. You may use timeSteps=799, but you may also use None (allowing variable amount of steps).

model.add(LSTM(units, input_shape=(None,2), return_sequences=True))
model.add(LSTM(2, return_sequences=True)) #it could be a Dense 2 too....
....
model.fit(X, Y, ....)

Predicting:

For predicting, create a similar model, now with return_sequences=False.

Copy the weights:

newModel.set_weights(model.get_weights())

You can make an input with length 800, for instance (shape: (1,800,2)) and predict just the next step:

step801 = newModel.predict(X)

If you want to predict more, we are going to use the stateful=True layers. Use the same model again, now with return_sequences=False (only in the last LSTM, the others keep True) and stateful=True (all of them). Change the input_shape by batch_input_shape=(1,None,2).

#with stateful=True, your model will never think that the sequence ended  
#each new batch will be seen as new steps instead of new sequences
#because of this, we need to call this when we want a sequence starting from zero:
statefulModel.reset_states()

#predicting
X = steps1to800 #input
step801 = statefulModel.predict(X).reshape(1,1,2)
step802 = statefulModel.predict(step801).reshape(1,1,2)
step803 = statefulModel.predict(step802).reshape(1,1,2)
    #the reshape is because return_sequences=True eliminates the step dimension   

Actually, you could do everything with a single stateful=True and return_sequences=True model, taking care of two things:

• When training, reset_states() for every epoch. (Train with a manual loop and epochs=1)
• When predicting from more than one step, take only the last step of the output as the desired result.