Welcome to OStack Knowledge Sharing Community for programmer and developer-Open, Learning and Share
Welcome To Ask or Share your Answers For Others

Categories

0 votes
626 views
in Technique[技术] by (71.8m points)

scala - The cost of nested methods

In Scala one might define methods inside other methods. This limits their scope of use to inside of definition block. I use them to improve readability of code that uses several higher-order functions. In contrast to anonymous function literals, this allows me to give them meaningful names before passing them on.

For example:

class AggregatedPerson extends HashSet[PersonRecord] {
  def mostFrequentName: String = {
    type NameCount = (String, Int)
    def moreFirst(a: NameCount, b: NameCount) = a._2 > b._2
    def countOccurrences(nameGroup: (String, List[PersonRecord])) =
      (nameGroup._1, nameGroup._2.size) 

    iterator.toList.groupBy(_.fullName).
      map(countOccurrences).iterator.toList.
      sortWith(moreFirst).head._1
  }
}

Is there any runtime cost because of the nested method definition I should be aware of?

Does the answer differ for closures?

See Question&Answers more detail:os

与恶龙缠斗过久,自身亦成为恶龙;凝视深渊过久,深渊将回以凝视…
Welcome To Ask or Share your Answers For Others

1 Answer

0 votes
by (71.8m points)

During compilaton, the nested functions are moveFirst and countOccurences are moved out to the same level as mostFrequentName. They get compiler synthesized names: moveFirst$1 and countOccurences$1.

In addition, when you refer to one of these methods without an argument list, it is lifted into a function. So map(countOccurences) is the same as writing map((a: (String, List[PersonRecord])) => countOccurences(a)). This anonymous function is compiled to a separate class AggregatedPerson$$anonfun$mostFrequentName$2, which does nothing more than forward to countOccurences$.

As a side note, the process of lifting the method to a function is called Eta Expansion. It is triggered if you omit the argument list in a context where a function type is expected (as in your example), or if you use _ in place of the entire argument list, or in place of each argument (val f1 = countOccurences _ ; val f2 = countOccurences(_).

If the code was directly in the closure, you would have one fewer method call in your stack, and one fewer synthetic method generated. The performance impact of this is likely to be zero in most cases.

I find it to be a fantastically useful tool to structure code, and consider your example very idiomatic Scala.

Another useful tool is using small blocks to initialize a val:

val a = {
   val temp1, temp2 = ...
   f(temp1, temp2)
}

You can use scalac -print to see exactly how Scala code is translated into a form ready for the JVM. Heres the output from your program:

[[syntax trees at end of cleanup]]// Scala source: nested-method.scala
package <empty> {

  class AggregatedPerson extends scala.collection.mutable.HashSet with ScalaObject {
    def mostFrequentName(): java.lang.String = AggregatedPerson.this.iterator().toList().groupBy({
      (new AggregatedPerson$$anonfun$mostFrequentName$1(AggregatedPerson.this): Function1)
    }).map({
      {
        (new AggregatedPerson$$anonfun$mostFrequentName$2(AggregatedPerson.this): Function1)
      }
    }, collection.this.Map.canBuildFrom()).$asInstanceOf[scala.collection.MapLike]().iterator().toList().sortWith({
      {
        (new AggregatedPerson$$anonfun$mostFrequentName$3(AggregatedPerson.this): Function2)
      }
    }).$asInstanceOf[scala.collection.IterableLike]().head().$asInstanceOf[Tuple2]()._1().$asInstanceOf[java.lang.String]();
    final def moreFirst$1(a: Tuple2, b: Tuple2): Boolean = scala.Int.unbox(a._2()).>(scala.Int.unbox(b._2()));
    final def countOccurrences$1(nameGroup: Tuple2): Tuple2 = new Tuple2(nameGroup._1(), scala.Int.box(nameGroup._2().$asInstanceOf[scala.collection.SeqLike]().size()));
    def this(): AggregatedPerson = {
      AggregatedPerson.super.this();
      ()
    }
  };

  @SerialVersionUID(0) @serializable final <synthetic> class AggregatedPerson$$anonfun$mostFrequentName$1 extends scala.runtime.AbstractFunction1 {
    final def apply(x$1: PersonRecord): java.lang.String = x$1.fullName();
    final <bridge> def apply(v1: java.lang.Object): java.lang.Object = AggregatedPerson$$anonfun$mostFrequentName$1.this.apply(v1.$asInstanceOf[PersonRecord]());
    def this($outer: AggregatedPerson): AggregatedPerson$$anonfun$mostFrequentName$1 = {
      AggregatedPerson$$anonfun$mostFrequentName$1.super.this();
      ()
    }
  };

  @SerialVersionUID(0) @serializable final <synthetic> class AggregatedPerson$$anonfun$mostFrequentName$2 extends scala.runtime.AbstractFunction1 {
    final def apply(nameGroup: Tuple2): Tuple2 = AggregatedPerson$$anonfun$mostFrequentName$2.this.$outer.countOccurrences$1(nameGroup);
    <synthetic> <paramaccessor> private[this] val $outer: AggregatedPerson = _;
    final <bridge> def apply(v1: java.lang.Object): java.lang.Object = AggregatedPerson$$anonfun$mostFrequentName$2.this.apply(v1.$asInstanceOf[Tuple2]());
    def this($outer: AggregatedPerson): AggregatedPerson$$anonfun$mostFrequentName$2 = {
      if ($outer.eq(null))
        throw new java.lang.NullPointerException()
      else
        AggregatedPerson$$anonfun$mostFrequentName$2.this.$outer = $outer;
      AggregatedPerson$$anonfun$mostFrequentName$2.super.this();
      ()
    }
  };
  @SerialVersionUID(0) @serializable final <synthetic> class AggregatedPerson$$anonfun$mostFrequentName$3 extends scala.runtime.AbstractFunction2 {
    final def apply(a: Tuple2, b: Tuple2): Boolean = AggregatedPerson$$anonfun$mostFrequentName$3.this.$outer.moreFirst$1(a, b);
    <synthetic> <paramaccessor> private[this] val $outer: AggregatedPerson = _;
    final <bridge> def apply(v1: java.lang.Object, v2: java.lang.Object): java.lang.Object = scala.Boolean.box(AggregatedPerson$$anonfun$mostFrequentName$3.this.apply(v1.$asInstanceOf[Tuple2](), v2.$asInstanceOf[Tuple2]()));
    def this($outer: AggregatedPerson): AggregatedPerson$$anonfun$mostFrequentName$3 = {
      if ($outer.eq(null))
        throw new java.lang.NullPointerException()
      else
        AggregatedPerson$$anonfun$mostFrequentName$3.this.$outer = $outer;
      AggregatedPerson$$anonfun$mostFrequentName$3.super.this();
      ()
    }
  }
}

与恶龙缠斗过久,自身亦成为恶龙;凝视深渊过久,深渊将回以凝视…
Welcome to OStack Knowledge Sharing Community for programmer and developer-Open, Learning and Share
Click Here to Ask a Question

2.1m questions

2.1m answers

60 comments

57.0k users

...