html - Floated Child Elements: overflow:hidden or clear:both?

Question

As a web developer I frequently will have two floated (child) divs inside of another (parent) div. Actually I do this all day long.

<style type="text/css">
    #left {float:left;}
    #right {float:right;}
</style>
<div id="parent">
    <div id="left" class="child">&nbsp;</div>
    <div id="right" class="child">&nbsp;</div>
</div>

This doesn't work without an extra bit of css/html because the parent doesn't automatically grow to fit floated children. There are two popular ways of overcoming that:
1) Add overflow:hidden to the parent's css.
2) Add a 3rd "clearing" child <br style="clear:both;" />.

I know there's a few other similar questions about such things, but my question is:

Which method is better and why? What are the pros and cons of each?

Answer 1

1. Hidden overflow - pretty solid method. The main disadvantage is if you set a height on the parent element, any overflow will be...well, hidden. I found this when creating a menu with floated list items - the submenus would not appear.

2. Clearing element - rather than a line break, I would use a div with height: 0; clear: both; since it won't create a gap below. This is a more solid method, the only disadvantage being an extra element in the markup.

3. Float the parent - in my experience there are too many situations where you don't want to float the parent element, so I would avoid it.

4. You can also use the generated content method:

   #parent:after {
     content: ".";
     visibility: hidden;
     clear: both;
   }
   

   This saves the need for an extra element in the markup, but it won't work in IE7 and below.

5. Use inline blocks - just remembered this method. Instead of floating the two columns, set them to display: inline-block and they will appear side-by-side:

   .child {
     display: inline-block;
     vertical-align: top;
   }
   

   Only thing you must remember with this method is if there is any whitespace between the close tag of one block and the opening tag of another, a space will appear between the columns (the size of which depends on the font so it difficult to gauge). As long as you do ...</div><div id=... then this method works fine and is superior to floating elements IMO.